Engagement is an issue for most employers as the economy comes back. How to make it happen? Six factors are required for true employee engagement, says consultant Keith Branham. Highly engaged workplaces score high on all six.
Branham, who is founder and principal of Keeping the People, Inc., offered his expertise at WorldatWork’s 2013 Total Rewards Conference and Exhibition held recently in Philadelphia.
Driver #1: Caring and Committed Senior Leaders
Branham points to the following differences between employers that are low-scoring and high-scoring on engagement:
Low-Scoring Employers: |
High-Scoring Employers: |
Isolated and self-interested management |
Servant mindset management |
Devalue employees |
Value employees |
“Give ‘em an inch and they’ll take a mile.” |
“If we give, they will give back.” |
Employee engagement is desirable. |
Employee engagement is critical for our business success. |
Result: Burned out employees giving |
Result: Nurtured workers |
HR budget cuts? Let us help. HR.BLR.com is your one-stop solution for all your HR compliance and training needs. Take a no-cost, no-obligation trial and get a complimentary copy of our special report Critical HR Recordkeeping—From Hiring to Termination. It’s yours—no matter what you decide.
Driver #2: Manager Effectiveness
Twenty-five percent of employees would fire their boss, says Branham. Consider this table of traditional coaching vs. a more contemporary approach:
Traditional |
Partnering |
Manager-driven |
Employee has input |
Parent-to-child |
Adult-to-adult |
HR exercise |
Manager’s tool |
Personality |
Results |
Vague goals |
Specific objectives |
Yearly event |
On-going |
Gets compliance |
Gets commitment |
Branham points to Winchester Hospital, a “Best Place to Work in Boston” company that started to focus on good feedback and engagement. Nurse turnover went from 20 percent to 7 percent, and the nurse vacancy rate plummeted from 19 percent to 2 percent.
Make a simple grid to rate your managers, says Branham:
|
Makes the numbers |
Doesn’t make numbers |
Treats people |
Keep these managers |
Coach these managers; if they don’t improve, take them out of management |
Doesn’t treat |
Coach these managers; if they don’t improve, take them out of management |
Eliminate these people |
Driver #3: Teamwork (Not “Us vs. Them”)
Teamwork is an important element of engagement, says Branham.
In one recent survey, he says, in which employees scored their reaction to the statement, “I feel loyal to my immediate team or work group,” employees from best place to work winners scored significantly higher than did those from nonwinners.
Find out what the buzz is all about. Take a no-cost look at HR.BLR.com, solve your top problem, and get a complimentary gift.
Driver #4: Job-Learning-Career
Today’s employees value job enrichment, learning, and the ability to see a future.
One company, faced with few promotional opportunities for high-potential employees, has embraced horizontal transfers. Critically, the company has made it clear that managers cannot stand in the way of employees who want to change jobs.
Branham points to four differing generational views of learning:
Traditionalists |
“I learned the hard way … you can, too!” |
Boomers |
“Train ‘em too much and they’ll leave.” |
X’ers |
“The more they learn, the more they stay.” |
Millennials |
“Continuous learning is a way of life.” |
At the beginning, Branham says, employees are overwhelmed. Then there’s a period where they are happily challenged, followed by a period of smooth sailing. But then boredom sets in, followed by indifference. New challenges are required. (Source: Rob Bennett, Passion Saving: The Path to Plentiful Free Time and Soul-Satisfying Work)
Driver #5: Feeling Valued and Respected
Branham notes 10 ways employees may feel devalued:
- Lack of simple appreciation
- Unfair recognition
- Too-little, too-late recognition
- Reward wasn’t meaningful
- Insufficient/Unfair pay
- Being ignored (not listened to, kept informed, or taken seriously)
- Being micro-managed, over-controlled, not trusted, not challenged
- Unacceptable physical surroundings or conditions
- Not provided with the right tools, resources, including staffing assistance (overworked)
- Nonperformers tolerated and rewarded
And, again, says Branham, best places to work companies scored higher on recognition than did non-best places companies.
Driver #6: Personal Well-Being and Work-Life Balance
There’s a mixed message being delivered to employees, says Branham. First of all, studies say that half of employees are burned out (some studies say more like three- quarters) yet the companies are offering wellness programs.
Here is Branham’s partial list of well-being practices at top-scoring companies:
- 4 weeks; paid vacation for all
- Childcare subsidy
- Eldercare services
- Annual week-long financial and health fairs
- Free on-site breast-cancer and blood pressure screenings
- “College Coach” program for parents
- Meeting-free days
- Discounts on fitness club memberships, weight loss programs
- Nutrition consultations
In tomorrow’s Advisor, more on engagement, plus an introduction to the all-HR-in-one-place website, HR.BLR.com®.
I love the distinction between compliance and commitment! What a great way of summing up the difference of short-sightedness and long-term thinking.
You have to wonder about the accuracy of those studies on burned out employees. “Burned out” is such a vague and subjective term, I’m curious how it’s assessed for purposes of these studies.
You are quoting Rob Bennett? Seriously? Well, there went any interest I had in following your advice.
good one, it did explain the true classifications of baby bommers, xs, ys( millennials)