You’re probably already aware of the danger of bias lawsuits, but there are many other legal threats in the HR arena. Today, California attorney and SPHR Allison West briefs us on defamation, negligence, and fraud lawsuits.
West is principal of Employment Practices Specialists in Pacifica.
References Can Lead To Defamation
In the HR world, defamation often rears itself in relation to references. What exactly is defamation in the reference context? West notes that it has to be a “false statement of fact.” So opinions aren’t defamation because they aren’t fact.
Some states offer a qualified privilege for those giving references (see below), so a statement also is not defamatory if it falls under the privilege.
The statement must be made about an employee, and it must be disclosed to a third person.
Finally, the statement must cause damage to the individual’s reputation or expose the individual to public ridicule, shame, hatred, or contempt.
The 3 Prerequisites for ‘Qualified Privilege’
Under many state laws, employers that give references may enjoy a qualified privilege; however, there are three characteristics that most states require:
The statement must have been made without malice (that is, not by someone who is trying to “get back” at someone else).
The statement must have been not widely broadcast but restricted to those with a need to know.
The statement must have been made about the employee’s performance or qualifications and not about other matters.
Is Truth a Defense?
Remember, says West, that “Truth is a defense in defamation cases.”
How to hire without fear in California—learn more.
Be Proactive About References
To avoid legal entanglements, employers should be proactive in dealing with references. West says that employers should start by ensuring that they maintain accurate and objective personnel files.
Then, obtain an authorization and a release from the employee before seeking a reference.
Also be sure to train supervisors and managers about your policies about the circumstances in which information may be released and which information may be released.
Make sure that managers and supervisors know to avoid actions that might be viewed as blacklisting (“You’ll never work in this town again.”). Blacklisting is a criminal offense in some states—including California, notes West.
Finally, use caution when writing reference letters as part of settlements, West says. It may be tempting to omit negative information, says West, but remember there is always the possibility of being sued for negligence for not revealing important information, for example, relating to violence.
Can We Talk ‘Off the Record’? No Such Thing.
Inform your managers that there’s no such thing as “off the record” when it comes to references, says West.
Negligent Hiring
Employers have a duty to exercise reasonable care in hiring, West says. Negligent hiring suits may arise if employers hire someone with known dangerous traits, or if a reasonable inquiry would have discovered that the individual posed a threat to others.
A fully updated guide to hiring well—and legally—in the Golden State. Learn more.
What If I Hire Through Agencies?
Are you safe if you hire through agencies? Don’t they do a background check? Agencies make money by placing people, West says. When she asks employers, they usually say, ”I think the agency does something.” That’s not good enough; find out what they do in the way of reference checks, West says.
In tomorrow’s CED, West’s tips for avoiding hiring-related lawsuits.
Download your copy of How To Survive an Employee Lawsuit: 10 Tips for Success today!
I’m curious if most HR people are willing to answer the question “would hire him/her again?”–or does even that seem too risky?