HR Management & Compliance

With Trump win, many employment initiatives in question

Recent employment initiatives undertaken by the Obama administration could be in jeopardy under Donald Trump’s presidency, but employers still need to comply with those laws and regulations for now, says one expert.

“In general, things are going to be pretty unpredictable,” said Connor Beatty, an associate with Brann & Isaacson  in Maine and editor of Maine Employment Law Letter. Not only has Trump never held public office, but he’s also changed his position on issues several times, Beatty said.

Current initiatives

A major issue likely on employers’ minds is the impending effective date of the new overtime rules. The U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) new regulations, which will require employers to pay overtime to all workers paid less than $913 per week ($47,476 annually), are set to take effect December 1.

A hearing on an injunction to halt the rules is scheduled for November 16. If the injunction request is denied, the court will hold a dismissal hearing on November 28. Experts, however, have largely recommended that employers achieve compliance with the new rules by at least Thanksgiving to avoid reclassifying employees as nonexempt in the middle of a workweek, which could create wage and hour problems.

Beatty said that changes to the rules are possible but employers still should count on the December 1 effective date. The court could temporarily stop the rules, but appeals likely would follow. A major roll back wouldn’t happen until after Trump takes office.

Employers, therefore, should err on the side of caution and comply with the rules until they hear otherwise. “This is not something that you can roll out in one day,” Beatty said. “Hopefully employers have already been thinking about this and have already started to have those conversations and figure out the changes that are going to work for them.”

Once Trump is in office, a likely change to the rules would be an exception for small businesses based on the number of employees or revenue, Beatty said. Trump has noted that the rules will be particularly painful for small businesses. “I think there probably will be an increased push to . . . either carve out exemptions or . . . delay implementation [for small businesses],” Beatty said.

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) also could see some changes, Beatty said, most notably the employer mandate, which requires companies with 50 or more full-time employees to offer healthcare benefits or face penalties. “Full-time” is defined as 30 hours per week. Beatty said that criterion could be the first to go. “I could see that 30-hours-a-week requirement being bumped up because the argument is that employers have an incentive to restrict hours right now for their part-time employees,” he said. “That’s certainly one area where we could see some changes.”

Trump’s promise for immigration reform also could affect employers. “I think there could be increased scrutiny on employers in terms of their I-9 compliance,” Beatty said. H-1B visas (so-called highly skilled visas) could be an issue, too. The United States gives out many H class visas each year to countries with large Muslim populations, he said. “If your business relies on visas or has a population of workers [who] may not be documented, I think that’s really going to potentially impact the business a lot.”

The same can be said for almost every Obama initiative, Beatty added. “There’s a wide range of potential changes.”

Broader implications

Regardless of what happens to individual initiatives, employers will certainly feel the long-term effects of a Trump presidency.

Of course, there’s the opportunity for new laws and regulations. Both Trump and Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton discussed the possibility of providing paid leave programs for workers. Trump has said that he would provide six weeks of paid leave for new mothers and that he’d fund it by cracking down on unemployment fraud.

Beatty noted that when polled, most Americans seem to support some type of paid family leave and that Trump’s interest in it represents a split from the traditional Republican platform. “That’s one to watch,” Beatty said.

And then there’s the opportunity to appoint at least one U.S. Supreme Court justice, lower court judges, and agency officials. Employers are likely to see a shift in agencies’ enforcement efforts, Beatty said. The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), which has had a progressive agenda in recent years, has two openings. We’ve even seen the NLRB focus on nonunion workplaces, but that may all change now, Beatty said. “If you switch the balance of power there it could take the agency in an entirely different direction.”

Similar logic applies to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC) initiatives, Beatty said, adding that employers may see more hostile workplace complaints because of a deeply divided country. “I see the potential for more complaints and enforcement actions on the grounds of either hostile workplace or sex and racial discrimination,” he said.

If the workplace debates that occurred before the election are any indication of future events, Beatty fears some employees may now feel emboldened to pay less attention to implicit biases. Employers must be wary of that, he said.

Beatty also warned that increases in unemployment—which economists have predicted will occur under Trump—have previously led to more equal employment opportunity claims. If employees believe they were wrongfully fired but are able to find new jobs easily, they may not file a claim. “But if they can’t put food on the table,” it’s a different story, Beatty said.


Need to learn more? Join us Friday, November 18, for the live webinar The Trump Presidency: How the New Administration May Impact Federal Workplace Laws and Regulations. BLR Senior Legal Editor Jennifer Carsen, JD, and  BLR Senior Managing Editor, HR and Compensation Catherine Moreton Gray, JD, will discuss implications for the Affordable Care Act, the overtime regs going into effect December 1, EEOC enforcement of gender identity and sexual orientation rights, federal government contractors’ requirements under President Obama’s Executive Orders, and enforcement activities by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). For more information, click here.