HR Management & Compliance

Career Karma Caught Up with This Rude Commuter!

Have you ever wondered why good things happen to bad people? I know I have. It’s not something I’m particularly proud of, but I must admit that sometimes I scratch my head and wonder how someone with questionable character or who demonstrates unethical behavior seemingly ends up on top.

The other day, I heard a story that made me smile. For me, it was proof that karma does exist and that sometimes the jackass reaps what he sows. Here’s the story.

Matt Buckland was riding to work on London’s subway, known as the Tube, one morning last week. As he tells the story, “I stood to one side to let a lady get by, and ended up blocking a man momentarily. He shoved past me, almost knocking me over, and shouted.” What the man shouted isn’t appropriate for a family audience. Let’s just say it involved a four-letter word that begins with F.

To most of us, this story isn’t all that surprising. We all encounter rude people on a routine basis. Who among us hasn’t had a similar thing happen to them on their way to work? But Buckland’s story didn’t end when the jerk pushed by him. In fact, that was just the beginning of the story.

You see, Buckland is the head of recruiting at UK-based Forward Partners. Later that day, he was scheduled to interview someone for a developer’s job with the company. Guess who walked in the door for the interview? You got it—the jerk from the Tube.


HR budget cuts? Let us help. HR.BLR.com is your one-stop solution for all your HR compliance and training needs. Take a no-cost, no-obligation trial and get a complimentary copy of our special report Critical HR Recordkeeping—From Hiring to Termination. It’s yours—no matter what you decide.


Buckland tweeted that day, “Karma—the guy who pushed past me on the tube and then suggested I go F myself just arrived for his interview … with me.” You gotta love social media!

And in case you’re wondering, the jerk didn’t get the job. Big surprise there!

Legendary basketball coach John Wooden said, “The true test of a man’s character is what he does when no one is watching.” Well, in this case, the man on the Tube showed his true colors when people were watching—he just didn’t know his actions would come back to haunt him. Who knows if he might have received a job offer that day if he hadn’t acted as he did? It does make you think about our interview processes and how we can get fooled by well-behaved candidates who know how the game is played. I can’t imagine the man would have behaved the same way in an interview as he did during that morning’s commute.

We want to hire team players who can get along with those around them and treat others with respect, and how someone treats other people—all people—tells you a lot about that person’s character and goodness. In this case, Buckland and Forward Partners dodged a bullet. We should all be so lucky as to have a chance encounter on the subway with every person we interview just to see how they respond when they don’t think anyone who matters is watching.

2 thoughts on “Career Karma Caught Up with This Rude Commuter!”

  1. I don’t know which would be more fun: meeting him at the door and thanking him for coming, then escorting him out, OR moving forward with the interview and allowing him to wallow in his discomfort for 30 minutes or so.

  2. Dan – great story! I used to work as the training manager for a company and one day noticed the HR Manager bring someone in for an interview. Then when done walk them out. I noticed she would stop by my desk smile at me and walk back out to the guard. My curiosity piqued I asked her what she was doing.

    She told me she always asked the guard how the applicant treated the guard when waiting. Was the person asking questions about her? The company? Responding to general conversation? Or did the applicant treat the guard like a servant in Downton Abbey?

    “As you sow…” covers it and if the person wasn’t nice to the guard they were not generally hired.

    To her credit she didn’t get that feedback until after her interview. She wasn’t biased but she was thorough!!!

    Enjoy your columns. Thanks for sharing!

    JT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *