In today’s economy, hiring should be easy. But that doesn’t change the fact that the hiring process is fraught with legal pitfalls, especially for unwary and untrained managers. Here are 8 of the most common, as listed by a prominent attorney. (The first 6 today, the balance tomorrow.)
Managers think they are doing a good job of interviewing and hiring, says Barbara Meister Cummins, but most of them are “traveling without a map.” Recently, Cummins, a New York City attorney, detailed the 8 most common mistakes in hiring. Her thoughts appeared in a recent issue of our sister publication, HR Manager’s Legal Reporter. Here are her “Top Failures”:
#1: Failure to Plan the ‘How’ to Get the Right ‘Who’
Too many managers start interviewing before they know what they are looking for. Start with an accurate job description, says Cummins. It’s the springboard for everything else. To get it right, you have to involve the people who work with the job, do the job, and supervise it. A good job description will:
–Help you define the requisite skills and qualifications.
–Separate out the “essential functions,” as required by the ADA.
–Lead to a matrix of criteria which provides a defense against discrimination claims.
To determine your hiring criteria, Cummins suggests the following:
–Focus on knowledge, skills, abilities, relevant job experience, education.
–Determine what is really necessary to succeed; not some “wish list.”
After you have decided your criteria, develop a series of questions that will help you to distinguish candidates with the attributes you seek.
#2: Failure to Use a Good Employment Application
Every applicant must fill out an employment application, Cummins says. She offers the following suggestions for a good application:
–Request relevant information only.
–Require the names of the last supervisor for each prior employer, and get authority to contact all references.
–Include acknowledgments stating that:
• If employed, the applicant will abide by the organization’s rules.
• The application is not a contract.
• Employment will be at will.
• Information provided is accurate, and if not, is grounds for discharge at any time.
• The applicant is not bound by any restrictive covenants, e.g., noncompetes.
Managers of small HR departments have found the special help they need in a unique BLR product—Managing an HR Department of One. Examine it at no cost or risk for 30 days. Click for info.
#3: Failure to Maintain Records of Applications
Recordkeeping is required by the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) for federal contractors, and is also necessary for defending possible discrimination claims.
Devise a policy for dealing with applicants and stick with it for both Internet and hard copy application submissions. (“This is how we look at submissions, this is how we review them, this is what we do with them.”)
#4: Failure to Train Interviewers
There are three common mistakes untrained interviewers make, says Cummins: impermissible questions, inconsistency, and overselling.
Impermissible Questions
Untrained managers tend to ask impermissible questions, such as:
–High school graduation date (“What class were you in?”)
–Origin of accent or unusual name (“That’s a pretty accent; where are you from originally?”)
–National origin (“How did you come to learn Farsi?”)
–Family or marital status (“Tell me about your family.”)
–Disability (“What happened to your foot?”)
Inconsistency
Whatever is asked, keep it consistent among candidates. One way to do this is with a set of written questions, all of which are asked of everyone.
Overselling
Promises to the applicant may be interpreted by courts as contracts, or may subject the employer to fraud or “promissory estoppel” legal problems.
Feel like you’re all alone in HR? Take on a partner—Managing an HR Department of One. Examine at no cost or risk for 30 days. Click for info.
#5: Failure to Ask About Restrictive Covenants
Ask applicants, “Are you subject to any agreements with your former employer that could prohibit your free employment with us or restrict you somehow?” If the answer is yes, get copies of the agreements and read them.
#6: Failure to Check References and Basic Application Information
Surveys show, says Cummins, that 56 percent of all applicants supply incorrect information in some significant area. Knowing this, you must perform background checks, she says.
In tomorrow’s Advisor, more maddening mistakes and an introduction to a program that’s helping many HR departments, and especially smaller ones, do better at hiring–and everything else.