Yesterday, we featured the first 6 “sins” of performance appraisers; today, we present the rest of the sins on our Top 10 list.
[Go here for sins 1 to 6.]
Sin #7. Gaming the system
“John’s work is just OK, to be sure, but I need to give him a big raise to keep him, so he gets an ‘excellent.’”
“I can’t stand Sandy, but I can’t transfer him unless he has a high rating; let his next manager deal with him.”
This is gaming the system, giving inaccurate ratings for some reason outside the performance appraisal realm. As we have mentioned, this is always going to lead to trouble—and probably very expensive trouble.
Sin #8. Failure to take performance appraisal seriously
“I’ve got real work to do, and here’s this stack of appraisals I have to get through.”
“Got to get these performance appraisals in. Good … good … good … good. Done.”
One would hope that managers would look at the appraisal process as an important opportunity to improve the performance of the department, help employees to develop, and give credit where it is due. But some view appraisals as an onerous chore.
That’s unfortunate. Not only will that manager lose the opportunity to improve performance and recognize hard work, but he or she is likely setting up a situation that an eager lawyer will jump on.
The only reference guide you need on your desk as a California HR professional. Learn more.
Sin #9. Failure to be consistent across department and organization or playing favorites
“Jim’s performance isn’t that great, but he’s my kind of guy.”
“Judy is a great worker, but her husband has a good job; I think the higher rating goes to Steve even though his work isn’t as good as hers.”
“Jamie is clearly the better producer, but if Tracy doesn’t get the high rating, Tracy will whine and complain; Jamie will just take it, so Tracy gets the high rating.”
Within the department or across the organization, if ratings are inconsistent, there are going to be complaints, morale problems, and eventually lawsuits. If the inconsistency is blatant (for example, if members of a protected class are consistently rated lower), that’s setting up for a lawsuit, especially if the sins of vague goals and “dishonest” evaluations are present.
Sin #10. Failure to document carefully
“They want me to write this stuff down, but I’m busy, and I’ll remember it.”
If there is ever a court case or charge, remember that it will likely be 2 to 5 years after the event that proceedings occur. Without clear contemporaneous documentation, even if all the players are still employed at your organization, it will be difficult to remember what exactly was said, and it will be very difficult to convince a jury.
Ok, that’s our 10 sins of performance appraisal. Avoid them, and you’ll likely avoid a lot of heartache, hassle—and expensive lawsuits.
You’re dealing with, what, a couple of dozen recurring challenges? In addition to performance appraiser “sins,” you’ve also got FMLA intermittent leave, overtime, ADA accommodation, and sexual harassment on your plate … and then some.
Unless you’re a research superstar, you might not know all you should about the nuances of California’s unique laws. Unlike the federal government, which puts all new regulations into the Federal Register, states publicize them in obscure journals that aren’t widely available. Yet officials still expect you to comply.
Fortunately, tools are available to help you keep up with state laws. One is our fully updated 2014 Guide to Employment Law for California Employers. This valuable desk reference has kept employers apprised of state law and its differences from the federal for years. Here are some reasons they tell us they won’t be without it:
Presents and Compares Federal and State Law on 200 Employment Topics. For each topic, first there’s a plain-English explanation of what you need for federal compliance. Then, right next to the federal, there’s an explanation of what California requires.
Topics Alphabetically Arranged. Pick today’s HR challenge, from “Affirmative Action” to “Workers’ Compensation,” and it’s easily found.
Highlights of the Main Changes to Both California and Federal Law for 2014. Easy-scan checklists provide a quick rundown of the main changes you need to be concerned about—turn to the appropriate section in the guide for a full explanation.
You’ll have easy access to:
- More than 1,300 pages of reliable, plain-English guidance on key HR issues arranged by topic in an easy-to-use, quick-reference format
- Highlights of the latest legal changes and developments from the past year
- Updates on new legislation and regulatory changes and what they mean for you in 2014
- Coverage of precedent-setting court decisions
- Quality overviews and analysis of both federal and California requirements
- And much, much more!
Best of all, the guide costs less than 77 cents each workday in 2014. Compliance peace of mind for less than your daily cup of coffee—you won’t find a better deal anywhere.
Click here to order your copy today. If you’re not 100 percent thrilled with it, just return it and pay nothing—there’s no risk to you.
Download your copy of Training Your New Supervisors: 11 Practical Lessons today!